Children are a heritage of the Lord. Psalm 127:3



July 30, 2010

The Waiting Place

One of the books that Matthew picked to read tonight was Oh! The Places You'll Go! (Dr. Seuss).  The line that made me smile:

The Waiting Place... for people just waiting
Waiting for a train to go, or a bus to come,
or a plane to go or the mail to come,
or the rain to go or the phone to ring
. . . everyone is just waiting.


(Still waiting)

July 29, 2010

All Quiet on the Referral Front

Our phone has been silent all day.  Seriously, doesn't someone (anyone!?) need to call me?  At least I can get that initial adrenaline rush before I look at the caller ID...  :)

July 26, 2010

The Big Picture

Each day that we wait for our referral seems so long.  I have the calendar memorized, yet I still insist on looking at it and counting the weeks... it is becoming increasingly likely that we will not be bringing our daughter home before Christmas, maybe not even until January. 

This morning, I had a funny conversation with Matthew.  He delights in killing the bugs that find their unfortunate way into our home.  Matthew pointed to one poor deceased creature and announced that he had "sent it to heaven," to which I responded that I do not know if bugs go to heaven or not.  This led to more questions: 

Matthew:  How do we get to heaven? Is it a long way?
Me:  Well... sort of.  Our bodies die and get buried, only our souls go to heaven.  Your soul is inside of you, you can't see it.
Matthew:  But how does it get out? Where is the door?

After getting wholly unsatisfactory answers from Mommy, he finally gave up asking questions.

This left me thinking about what I will leave behind when my name is finally etched in stone: God willing, faithful children who love God and love their neighbor.   Beyond that, a lot of other things that will fade with time:  good memories, bad photos, outdated clothing... a blog book with all of my inane postings.  My impatience this year will look all the more foolish in hindsight, when my children and grandchildren read these posts and laugh at my obsession with a few months.

Thinking about The Big Picture, I shake my head and smile. 

July 25, 2010

Filling Time

Playing with the blog design is turning out to be more fun that I expected!

July 22, 2010

Patience is Overrated

The whole patience thing lasted a day. So much for that!

I insist on stretching and thinking "what if..." My unrealistic but optimistic side is taking over:

IF we get a referral SOON
we MIGHT get a court date in early October and
IF we pass court the first time and
IF the embassy doesn't decide to open an investigation on our file
we MIGHT get an embassy appointment in November...
which would mean bringing her home in four months, before Christmas!?!?

Pray.

July 21, 2010

Waiting Patiently. Really.

The impossible has finally happened: I am waiting PATIENTLY! Yes, really, I am, and all because of "bad" news. Go figure.

The court in Ethiopia is no longer scheduling hearings: they have closed for the rainy season. As close as we are (and we are so very close!), whether we receive our referral today or next month, we will likely travel for Trip #1/court in October/November, with Trip #2/Gotcha Day in December/January. For many months, we had hoped that we would have our daughter home by now. Hah! But... at least now we KNOW. Knowing is better, I think...

Now that courts have closed, a later referral has its advantages: a shorter wait time between referral and Gotcha Day (maybe?), meaning a little less heartache (maybe?). I know that I will be even more anxious, even more impatient, even more frustrated, once I have her photo, know her story, start to bond with her from 8,000 miles away. Every month that I cannot dry her tears, kiss her cheek, snuggle with her, and rock her to sleep will make such a difference, so waiting for a referral is suddenly okay with me.

The phone will ring someday. For now, I have places to go, people to see... okay, who am I kidding? I have a house to clean and laundry to do!

In the meantime... the verse that I have stuck in my head this afternoon: This is the day that the Lord has made. Let us rejoice and be glad in it! (Psalm 118)

July 19, 2010

#1!

In 40 long weeks, we've gone from #47 to #1 on the Wait List for an infant girl.

40 weeks... sound familiar? :)

The next phone that rings with an infant girl referral will be ours...

Oh yeah!!

July 11, 2010

Relinquishment by Fathers

When I think of single parents giving up their children, I usually think of mothers. Yet as I sit here thinking about my daughter and wondering what her story will be, I am struck by the numbers: in Ethiopia, orphans who have lost one parent are more often relinquished by a surviving father than by a surviving mother.

34% (1.6 million) of Ethiopia's 4.8 million orphans are "maternal" orphans who have a living father. 52% (2.5 million) are "paternal" orphans who have a living mother. (The remaining 14% are "dual" orphans who have lost both parents.) Yet 32% of maternal orphans (525,000) do not continue living with their father, compared to 20% of paternal orphans (508,000): widowed fathers give their children up more often than widowed mothers. While I have had it in my mind that my daughter will either be abandoned or relinquished by a single/widowed mother, if she is relinquished, her surviving parent may well be her father.***

That "feels" different to me. It shouldn't, but it does. As I sit here at 5 a.m. on this beautiful Sunday morning, I wonder if relinquishment by fathers breaks my heart a little less because I am a mother, and identify more closely with her?


***It is not necessarily more likely that relinquished children who are living in orphanages/available for adoption have a surviving father, despite the statistics: 90% of children who do not live with the surviving parent go to live with extended family, but that may break down differently between mothers/fathers. For example, perhaps fathers generally rely on extended family more often than mothers, and more often send their children to live with relatives as a matter of course, but children who end up in orphanages/unrelated care more often have a surviving mother without extended family support? I also imagine that a higher percentage of children under the age of 12 months (our parameters) are relinquished by their mothers rather than their fathers, because a mother who gives birth to a healthy infant is less likely than her husband to die of i.e. AIDs or malaria within the first few months. The statistics do not break down into this much detail... (Statistics published by UNICEF, Africa's Orphaned and Vulnerable Generations, www.unicef.org/adolescence/files/Africas_Orphaned_and_Vulnerable_Generations_Children_Affected_by_AIDS.)

July 9, 2010

We're #3!

Unoffially... but firmly... #3!

Officially we're still #6, but... we know that two families ahead of us received infant girl referrals *this week,* and one family ahead of us is open to a toddler, not an infant, so... *drum roll please* ... we are #3 in line for an infant girl referral!

In staring at the referral chart below, I have found a pattern. It may be real, or it may be the result of too much ice cream and too little sleep, but either way, here it is: This year, infant girl referrals by our agency seem to consistently alternate months, with high numbers in odd months and low numbers in even months: February/2, March/4, April/2, May/5, June/1. If July follows this pattern, we may have a referral by the end of the month!

This makes me happy.

July 7, 2010

Ask Grandma

Our neighbors are home with their adorable baby girl! I have especially loved watching Matthew interact with her. He delights in touching her (oh so soft!) hands and talking to her in this hilarious falsetto toddler voice :“ooohh you’re sooo pretty….your hands are sooo soft….aaawwww.”

His first description of Magdalyn to my mom went like this: Matthew, in an excited voice, “The Rogers’ baby sister is so pretty! Her name is MAG-da-lyn! And she’s black all over!” Then suddenly, for the first time since we started pouring over photos of Ethiopian children and watching Gotcha Day videos, it occured to him to wonder: “Why is she black, Grandma?” Grandma, without missing a beat, explained: “Babies are like kitties, they come in all different colors!”

I love my boy, and I love my mom!

And... I'm glad he asked Grandma instead of me! Silly me, my answer would have trailed off into melanin...

July 1, 2010

Different Kinds of Numbers

I've decided to take a break from counting Wait List and Referral Numbers, and instead count different kinds of numbers.

The following is my continuing compilation of facts as I prepare a more complete response to the challenge that international adoption is essentially wrong. I absolutely agree that adoption should not be the only response to the orphan crisis in Ethiopia, but I am also convinced that it is the best option for many of the individual children living in orphanages, whether they are there because they are (a) "double orphans" (having lost both parents), with no extended family able or willing to take them in, (b) relinquished by a living parent, or (c) abandoned.

I have heard the orphan crisis described as a "myth," largely because statistics commonly cited by supporters appear to be exaggerated. Yes, there are over 50 million orphans in sub-Saharan Africa,14 but critics of international adoption will quickly point out that this number is primarily comprised of children who have lost only one parent, and of those who have lost both parents, most are living with extended family.

This is all true, however, there are still a number of children in need of a permanent home - not 50 million, to be sure, but a number that is still far higher than the current rate of international adoption. In addition, parents throughout the world give their babies up for adoption for other reasons, just as parents in the U.S. do. In countries like Ethiopia, where the average birth rate is high and the average income is low, adoption of unrelated children is almost non-existent. For children living in orphanages, international adoption may be their best opportunity for a stable, loving home.

I am trying to obtain the most current, accurate statistics in advocating for international adoption. Whatever the numbers - 130 million or 13,000 - this I know: there is one child in need of a home, and I will welcome that child with loving arms into my family.

***updated July 10, 2010***

Ethiopia is the oldest independent country in Africa, one of the oldest countries in the world (over 2,000 years), and the second-most populous country in sub-Saharan Africa. The three colors of its flag, adopted in the late 1800’s, have been copied so much by other countries that they have become known as the Pan-African colors. The coffee bean, adored by my husband along with tens of millions of other coffee addicts-aka-connoisseurs, originated in Ethiopia. With its rich soil, Ethiopia continues to be the top coffee producing country in Africa. The country’s diverse terrain includes breathtaking waterfalls, some of the highest mountains in Africa (4,500 meters), and one of the hottest places on earth (Dallol).3,11 It also has the distinction of having the most UNESCO World Heritage Sites in Africa.3

The country is 1.1 million sq. km. (about twice the size of Texas, or the size of France and Spain combined), with a population of 88 million people1 and a life expectancy of 57.4 Nearly half of the population is under the age of 14, and less than 3% are over the age of 65.1 Although there are about 80 total ethnic groups in Ethiopia, 85% of the population is divided between 7 ethnic groups.1 61% of Ethiopians are Christian, and 33% are Muslim.1

Economics. The per-capita Gross National Income is $280/year13. The minimum wage is 8 birr/day (USD 60 cents).10 Nearly 40% of the population is below the poverty line, living on less than $1.25/day.2 Agriculture accounts for 45% of the GDP13 and 85% of employment.1

Civil war and political conditions have contributed to the economic conditions. Unique among African countries, the ancient Ethiopian monarchy maintained its freedom from colonial rule with the exception of a short-lived Italian occupation from 1936-41. In 1974, a military junta, the Derg, deposed Emperor Haile Selassie (who had ruled since 1930) and established a socialist state. Torn by bloody coups, uprisings, wide-scale drought, and massive refugee problems, the regime was finally toppled in 1991 by a coalition of rebel forces, the Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front. A constitution was adopted in 1994, and Ethiopia's first multiparty elections were held in 1995.3

Despite the regime change, the state continues to own all of the land9;10: citizens may lease land, but may not sell or transfer it. State ownership of land is the primary impediment to larger, more efficient farming operations, and the main cause of poor cultivation practices and low productivity.

Poverty is compounded as the cycle continues: because families only lease a small amount of land, they cannot afford to do anything but farm it to its maximum capacity, without a break (lying fallow or crop rotation). Overfarming causes soil degradation, which reduces the production of fodder for livestock, which causes low milk yields and declining livestock populations, which leads to less fertilizer available for farming (manure is also burned as fuel), which contributes to lower crop production, which increases poverty, which leads to additional hunger, malnutrition, and disease, all of which further challenge individuals’ physical ability to farm, and pressures continuing overuse of the land.3,9

The absence of private property also stifles growth in non-ag (e.g. industry) sectors. The government has a monopoly on the telephone system, which remains substandard. There are fewer than 1 million landline phones and 3 million cell phones, which amounts to less than 1 phone for every 20 people.1

Health. 94% of births do not have a skilled attendant present; 4% of women will die in childbirth.2 Although the infant mortality rate has improved over the past five years, it is still nearly 7%.2 Of the children who survive birth, another 4% will die before their 5th birthday.2 (The overall mortality rate 0(birth)- 5 years old is 11%.2,4) Over 60% of the population do not have access to safe drinking water4;11,13, and 90% do not have access to adequate sanitation facilities4. 2% of the population is infected with HIV.4 The doctor/population ratio is 1:42,000.8,12

Children. Child (5 - 14 years) labor is over 50%, as is child marriage.2 40% of children under 5 are moderately to severely underweight, and 50% are moderately to severely stunted.2 Only 45% of children attend primary school2, and nearly 60% of the population is illiterate.1 The primary reason children do not attend school in rural areas is the children are needed for farm work (48% boys, 16% girls) and housework (53% girls, 16% boys).17

Orphans in Africa. UNICEF, studies, and related literature now use the term "orphan" to describe both "half orphans" (children who have lost one parent) and "double orphans" (children who have lost both parents). This can be somewhat misleading, as most people think of "orphans" as children who do not have a parent to care for them -- by UNICEF's definition, I was an orphan when I lost my father at a young age, but my mother certainly did not see me as such!

By this broad definition, over 50 million children in sub-Saharan Africa are "orphans".15 This includes 7 million total orphans under the age of 5, and 1 million double orphans under the age of 5.15 90% of double orphans and single orphans who do not live with their surviving parent live with extended family (often siblings or grandparents).15 Children under the age of 5 are the most vulnerable. For example, children 0- 3 are four times more likely to die within a year (before/after) of their mother’s death.15

Orphans in Ethiopia. There are 5 million orphans in Ethiopia2,14, 18% of whom have lost at least one parent to AIDs. 34% of orphans have lost their mother, 52% have lost their father, and 14% (700,000) have lost both parents.15 Of the more than 13 million children in Ethiopia who are under age 52, 4% (over 500,000) have lost at least one parent.15  80% of paternal orphans live with their surviving mother, and 68% of maternal orphans live with their surviving father.15 Orphans are significantly less likely to attend school than non-orphans, are significantly more likely to suffer abuse and exploitation, and are significantly more likely to “think that [their] life will be bad.”15 75% of children 10 - 14 who have lost both parents do not attend school.15

Abandonment. Child abandonment is "disturbingly common" throughout Africa.18 While the reasons for abandonment vary, a large number are by unwed, often young, mothers. In Ethiopia, premarital pregnancies (sometimes the product of rape18) are not uncommon, yet children born out of wedlock are often rejected by their families and denied by their fathers. These children are considered "excess" - unwanted and unvalued - and are treated as inferior to legitimate children, receiving less food, less education, and more work.17

Orphanages. I have been unable to find reliable statistics on Ethiopian orphanages. "There is much that remains unknown about the number of children in residential care in sub-Saharan Africa because estimates are available for only a limited number of countries."15 Extrapolating from the orphan statistics that are available, however, I estimate that there are well over 10,000 children in Ethiopia under the age of 5 who are likely living in orphanages (or who would be but for international adoption):

If there are 500,000 orphans under 5, of which over 325,000 live with a surviving parent (34% are maternal orphans, of which 68% live with surviving father; 52% are paternal orphans, of which 80% live with surviving mother, and 14% are double orphans), there are 175,000 orphans who do not live with a parent. If 90% of these orphans are cared for by extended family (consistent with sub-Saharan Africa statistics), there are 17,500 orphans whose living situations are unaccounted for. Even if 40% (?) of these orphans are cared for by non-relatives, at least 10,000 orphans under 5 are still unaccounted for and may be living in orphanages. This figure does not include the thousands of abandoned children living in orphanages. These numbers increase daily, as children continue to be orphaned and abandoned.

I am also unable to find statistics related to the long-term success of children who live for extended periods of time in orphanages in Ethiopia. Some information is available for Russia, however. Like Ethiopia, Russian orphanages "release" children by the time they are 16. With no family support or other resources, 40 percent become homeless, 20 percent become criminals and 10 percent commit suicide.16

International adoption in the U.S. has sharply declined in recent years, from its peak of almost 23,000 in 2004 to less than 13,000 in 2009.5 Compare to approximately 50,000 children/year adopted out of U.S. foster care6, and approximately 14,000 U.S.-born  infants adopted privately each year7. Infants privately adopted in the U.S. are almost exclusively relinquished by unmarried white women.7 29% of the internationally-adopted children currently living in the U.S. have special needs, and one-third were adopted from China6, where families are limited by law to 1 child. 70% of children adopted internationally were previously living in institutional group homes (aka orphanages).6

In 2009, fewer than 5,000 children were adopted from Ethiopia, including fewer than 2,500 by families in the U.S.5

(1)Central Intelligence Agency - The World Factbook
(2)UNICEF
(3)Wikipedia.org, citing various sources
(4)World Health Organization
(5)U.S. Department of State Office of Children’s Issues
(6)National Survey of Children’s Health,
(7)Based on resources cited by the Child Welfare Information Gateway
(8)World Health Organization
(9)See e.g. http://www.ideels.uni-bremen.de/land.html; http://www.wikipedia.org/, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethiopia
(10) The Guardian

(11)World Vision
(12)The Global Fund
(13) The World Bank Group
(14)UNICEF, Children on the Brink 2004: A Joint Report on New Orphan
Estimates and A Framework for Action, Appendix 1

(15) UNICEF, Africa's Orphaned and Vulnerable Generations
(16) New York Times, A Summer of Hope for Russian Orphans
(17) Africa Region Human Development Working Paper Series, Issues in Child Labor in Africa, citing various sources
(18) Los Angeles Times, Kenya widow opens arms to abandoned child, December 2009

June 30, 2010

Waiting on Wait Times

Wait times for healthy infant girls are increasing for families adopting from Ethiopia through our agency. Wait times for families adopting through other agencies have apparently not increased as significantly.

Our agency, AGCI, seems to have stable referral rates regardless of the number of families on the wait list, so as the wait list grows, the wait time increases. Other agencies seem to increase their referral rates as their wait lists grow. Through conversations with a variety of people, we have pieced together the following possible explanation. (If you have additional or different information, please let me know!)

Background. In Ethiopia, there are licensed orphanages and licensed adoption agencies. Orphanages provide long-term care for orphaned, relinquished and abandoned children, advocating on behalf of the child, while agencies facilitate adoptions, advocating on behalf of the adoptive family. Before a child is eligible for adoption, their file must be in order, and their status carefully documented and confirmed.

AGCI Referral Process. AGCI works closely with only one or two orphanages. These orphanages have been carefully selected, based in part on their standards of care and ethics, and their staff receive additional training from our agency.

As the orphanage identifies children in its care who are eligible for adoption, it contacts AGCI. If AGCI believes that it can place the child with an adoptive family, it accepts the child into its care at its transition home, Hannah's Hope.

At Hannah's Hope, each child receives nutrition, medical care and individual attention (the ratio of caregivers to infants is 1:3). Every family who has brought their child home from Hannah's Hope says the same thing: the special mothers LOVE the children, and it shows in everything they do.

Depending on the child's condition and age, AGCI may refer the child to a family within days, weeks or months; AGCI works with the child to help him/her get healthy prior to referral. If a child has special needs, AGCI will match him/her with a family that is open to and equipped to assist that particular child. A child is never referred to a family until he/she is in care at Hannah's Hope.

All of this diligence and care takes time.

Other Agencies' Referral Process. In contrast, other agencies may visit dozens of orphanages to proactively identify children who fit the parameters of their waiting families, referring children to families straight from orphanages, with no interim transition home like Hannah's Hope.

One upside to this approach is that children and families are matched much faster: there is "one less" waiting child today, rather than tomorrow or next month. The downsides may include a longer wait time between referral and "gotcha day," as a child's paperwork may not be in order because the orphanage staff is not properly trained. In addition, children may not receive the same level of care, either before referral (which may lead to unidentified needs), or after referral (which may lead to children being malnourished and with more temporary health challenges when families bring them home).

Point of View. As a waiting family frustrated with the wait times, I find myself almost jealous of families adopting through other agencies who started the process after us and have already returned home with their children. I know, however, that the day we receive a referral I will be grateful that (a) it is less likely that my daughter has unidentified special needs that we are not prepared for, (b) she is, on that very day, receiving exceptional care, love and attention in my absence, and (c) the referral-to-gotcha-day timeline will not be extended because of inadequate paperwork. As tough as the wait is now, after I have her photo and know her name, the wait will be all the more unbearable, and the care that she is receiving in the meantime will be all the more precious.

For now, I have concluded that there is no "right" or "wrong" approach to referrals because the end goal is the same: uniting families to serve the child, bless the parents, and change the world.

June 21, 2010

HyperCrunch

REFERRALS and WAIT LIST #s
as reported in periodic updates

Egads. This isn't pretty. Does anyone have a better way of creating a table like this in Blogger?

If not... here is a painful-but-functional chart of referrals as reported in the twice-monthly agency Updates, beginning with the last half of August. It confirms what we have been told, that monthly referrals are "on track," with 2-3 official (accepted) referrals/month in each Infant category. Despite my feeling - shared by others! - that referrals have stalled, the May Update included an exceptionally high number of referrals.

The increasingly longer wait times is apparently the result of the increasing number of families on the Wait Lists, rather than a decline in referral rates. While the number of waiting families has increased 50% since August, the rate of referrals has remained relatively stable for Girls (rolling 4-month average of 4/month), with a significant (almost 100%) increase for Boys (rolling 4-month average jumping from 11 to 20). Note: Because many families are on both the Boy and Girl wait lists, an increase in Boy referrals will have some impact on the wait time for families on the Girl list, as families receive Boy referrals and come off the Girl list.

As we know first-hand, the wait time for referrals is steadily increasing. Date on Wait List : Time to Referral for a healthy infant Girl looks like this:

  • July 2009 : 6 months
  • August 2009 : 7-8 months
  • September 2009 : 8-9+ months (some still waiting)
  • October 2009 : 9+ months (all still waiting)

This (over)anlysis does not change a darn thing, but somehow it makes me feel better.

Any additional insights are appreciated!

_____________Infant___Toddler___Infant___Toddler_____Boy_______Girl
_____________BOY____BOY_____GIRL____GIRL______LIST#_____LIST#

August__________0_______0________1________2_________17________40
September_______2_______2________1________0_________14________46
________________2_______0________2________0_________16________49
October_________1_______0________4________0_________16________45
________________2_______0________5________0_________18________47
November_______1_______0________2________0_________24________42
________________1_______0________0________0_________31________48
December_______0_______0________2________0_________31________47
[if there was a 2nd December update, I am missing it]
January_________3_______1________2________0_________34________47
________________1_______2________1________2_________32________49
February________3_______0________2________0_________34________50
[if there was a 2nd February update, I am missing it]
March__________3_______0________3________1_________31________52
________________2_______2________1________1_________36________52
April ___________0_______1________0________ 0________ 31________48
________________2_______1________2________1_________30________50
May____________1_______0________3________1_________36________51
________________5_______0________2________1_________33________54

June____________0_______0________0________0_________37________62
________________1_______2________1________0_________41________71

10 Month Totals___30_______11_______34________9
Monthly Average___3.0_______1.1______3.4_______.9

June 9, 2010

Officially #7... Unofficially #5... and counting!

I just finished another bowl of ice cream with hot chocolate sauce. It may not change the numbers, but it certainly puts them in perspective. Or maybe it just makes me happy. Let's not overanalylze that one.

The family at Official #3 on the Baby Girl Wait List just received a referral of a precious 14 month old baby girl. Their parameters were 0 - 14 months, so it may be that the referral "skipped" the unknown familes at #1 and #2 (if their parameters were the usual 0 - 12 months). Apparently, when they set their parameters, Family #3 bumped their parameters up to 14 months based on prayer and the advice of their social worker. Now they have the girl of their dreams who was meant for them. How awesome is that? I am so happy for them.

Selfishly, I am also happy for me. It means that we are that much closer to our own miracle.

I also learned today that one of the families on The List has higher age parameters - they are not open to 0 - 12 months (their bundle of joy will be toddling) - so on the strictly 0 - 12 month list we are one more closer to the Referral Call. That makes us unofficially-UNOFFICIALLY #5, at least!

Let's crunch the numbers. Since we hit the #7 spot several weeeks ago, the Unofficial List has included families in spots #3, #4, #6, and #7 (us). #3 has shared that they received their referral call this week. #1, #2, or #5 (we're not sure which) has higher age parameters. It is possible that, of the remaining two unidentified families in spots #1, #2, and #5, at least one has also received a referral that we do not know about. In that case, we could be #4. #4!?

We are getting closer to the much-anticipated Referral Call. Not as quickly as my imperfectly impatient improbable self foolishly and quite uselessly demands... but, what's a girl to do?

Oh yes. Eat more ice cream.

P.S. If you are one of the unidentified families ahead of us on the list, please do not think that I am stalking you. I respect your privacy. I do. I myself would not usually blog on a personal level like this, but after anonymously devouring the information that others posted on their blogs, I thought it only fair that I reciprocate. The alternative, to me, is giving up the information gluttony. That I couldn't do because, in some twisted way, every scrap of information helps me cope. So please do not be offended if I make guesses about your situation and offend your sensibilities. I know your story is personal to you, but in my corner of the world, your story is intertwined with mine, and I am sharing as best I know how.

June 7, 2010

New Court Process = Another Month Delay?

By now, everyone remotely connected to Ethiopia adoption - certainly anyone on my friends and family list! - knows that adoptive parents are required to travel twice to Ethiopia. The first trip is to attend the Ethiopia court hearing, and the second trip is to meet with the U.S. Embassy to obtain a VISA and bring our child(ren) home.

What we have just learned is that "court" will now consist of two hearings, adding as much as a month to the process. The latest information is that the court will hold the first hearing as usual, 4 - 6 (?) weeks after a referral is accepted by the adoptive parents. The birth family will be required to attend this first hearing (as has been required all along). Adoptive parents will be required to attend the new second hearing, a few weeks (give or take?) later. The Embassy appointment will be another 4 - 6 weeks after "passing" court.

Our best-guess timeline now looks like this:

- Receive a Referral: July/August
- Courts close: August - September
- First court hearing for birth family: October/November
- Second court hearing for us: November/December
- Embassy Appointment: December/January

We continue to pray that this is a pessimistic outlook, and the reality will be much shorter. We hope to know more later this week, after we speak with our caseworker.

My optimistic side - not the side that usually wins the argument, but it makes an effort from time to time - prays prays prays for a timeline that looks more like this:

- Receive a Referral: End of June
- First hearing: End of July
- Second hearing: Mid-August (courts, stay open!)
- Embassy Appointment: September

Time to buy more ice cream.

June 6, 2010

Still #7

We will get our official waitlist number later this week, but as far as we know, we are STILL #7 on the baby girl list. We have been on the list 8 months, and had expected to be making travel plans by now.

This delay has me second-guessing everything. I am emotionally exhausted, frustrated, angry, confused...

Jon, of course, has a great attitude about it all. Him, after hearing me grumble for the umpteenth time today: "Everything happens for a reason!" Okay, I know that. Yes! Intellectually, I KNOW that! Can I get some sympathy anyways? How about "Okay, honey, you're right, poor you, here's a shoulder to cry on? Is that pity potty comfortable enough for you?"

My emotions continue to rebel against my mind. I've tried bribing them with chocolate, ice cream, potato chips, and finally ice cream with chocolate, but they are still rebelling. Meanwhile, I've gained 5 pounds in a day, which isn't going to help my attitude when I step on the scale tomorrow.

The irony of it all does not escape me. I am in the same emotional state that I was in when I found out we were expecting Matthew. "God, I KNOW that your plan is perfect, but come on, really? [tears] Have you looked at our budget? [frustration] Have you looked at our plans? [anger] Are you sure you didn't make a mistake? [confusion] It sure feels like it to me... [tears]" Even the potato chips and ice cream binge is all too familiar - and if this continues, I'll gain the same 50+ pounds this time 'round. Joy.

Yet, Matthew couldn't be more perfect. The timing couldn't have been more perfect. Everything worked out... well, perfectly.

And here we are again. Only this time, I cannot WAIT to hold my baby girl, and all I'm hearing is "Wait." Wait longer. And longer.

Let's recap. In the past 8 months, our agency has sent out 2 - 5 baby girl referrals a month. If the referral hiatus ends tomorrow, the earliest we may get a referral is July/August. The courts in Ethiopia close August and September for the rainy season. This puts us with a court date in October/November and a Gotcha day in December. December!

Deep breath. Okay.

Pray.

Pray for our daughter, who may not even be born yet. Pray for her birth family, who is struggling with issues that make my timing frustrations all the more petty. Pray for Ethiopia government officials coordinating adoption, as they continue to be overworked and understaffed. Pray for the orphanages and their workers, as they do their best to care for children with very limited resources. Pray for our agency's staff, as they too are burdened with the additional demands of the new two-trip policy and related processing delays. Pray that everything will fall into place and we will bring our daughter home much sooner than it seems possible at this time. Pray that we will have peace as we wait.

God's will be done.

Now where's the rest of that ice cream?

May 20, 2010

(Still) Unofficially #7

If staring at the Unofficial List could possibly inspire movement, we would have our referral by now. I have not only stared, but parsed, counted, recounted, and speculated about where we might be, where we should be, where we could be, "what if" and "if only."

During a brief break from the obsessive list staring, I ordered hair bows today - http://www.theprincessandme.etsy.com/ - beautiful hair bows that will look too stinking cute on a certain gorgeous curly little head. What began as a distraction ended as a reminder of how ready I am to bring my sweet girl home.

Even though I KNOW we will not be getting any news at midnight on a Thursday night, here I am... waiting...

May 16, 2010

What Matthew Thinks

A 3-year old's perspective always makes me smile:

1. What is something you will say to your baby sister?
>I love her, that’s what I will say. Can we call her?

2 Where is your baby sister at now?
>E-thee-OH-peee-uh.

3. Where is Ethiopia?
>Across the ocean!

4. How will you make your baby sister laugh?
>When I laugh, it will make her laugh.

5. What will make your baby sister cry?
>I don’t know that question.

6. What will you do when she cries?
>Give her hugs and kisses and sing her songs.

7. What will your baby sister look like?
>She will look like a baby.

8. What will your baby sister like to do?
>I don’t think she can use my sword yet, not till she’s big. Little babies can’t use swords.

9. What will you do with your baby sister?
>Give her hugs and kisses, and I will pat her and stuff.

10. What do you like about your baby sister?
>I don’t like her crying but I like her to be happy.

11. What will your baby sister like to eat?
>Do babies eat croutons or carrots, or not? Or cucumbers?

12. How are you and your baby sister the same?
>I don’t know that one.

13. How are you and your baby sister different?
>My baby sister won’t watch TV.

14. Will you share your toys with your baby sister?
>Yes. If she shares her toys, I will share my toys.

15. Will you share Mommy and Daddy with your baby sister?
>Yes, my daddy will be her daddy, okay?

April 23, 2010

Unofficial Wait List

I find myself looking forward more and more to the Unofficial Wait List that comes out on Fridays. This list is maintained by other families in the AGCI Ethiopia program. The thought of doing all the calculations makes my head spin, so I will never volunteer, but I do so very much appreciate those who step up to the plate. The Unofficial List makes my day - thank you!

The List works like this: families voluntarily submit their information to the List Master (date added to the Official List and waitlist #). This information is kept confidential by our agency, so the List Master only has voluntarily-submitted information to work from. Because only about 1/3rd of families participate, the Unofficial information is sketchy, but... it's still more information, and I have become an information addict.

As families voluntarily post their referral news, the List is updated accordingly. The past two weeks, there has been a flood of referrals. With all of this activitiy, we are now...*drum roll please*...

UNOFFICIALLY #8/girl!

If referrals continue at this rate, we may receive our referral by the end of May/beginning of June! This would give us a court date in June/July (well before rainy-season closures August-September), and a 'gotcha' day in July/August...

Yes, I'm doing it again. Obsessive number crunching and calender counting. I can't help myself. We have been in the Ethiopia Program since July 2009. There is a reason pregnancy is 9 months - less time and you wouldn't be ready, more time and you would pull your hair out. Well, the stork has been traveling 10 months, and it's time to land. This mama is going stir crazy!

April 18, 2010

Referral News!

Our friends Bob & Cheri received a referral earlier this week! Cheri was at our house when the unexpected call came in - what a blessing to share such special moments with their family, to see their faces as they took in the news, saw her photo for the first time, laughed, hugged, and fell in love with her from 8,471 miles away. Their 7 week old bundle of joy is too adorable for words. We are looking forward to watching her story unfold as our families grow...grow up...grow old...together! http://sharing.theflip.com/session/8c54489b8851f644a8fd52225b753503/video/12916677

April 14, 2010

Good News on Travel

The U.S. Department of State has confirmed that as of May 9, adoptive parents will be required to attend the court hearing in Ethiopia. The good news is that only one parent must travel for court. http://adoption.state.gov/news/ethiopia.html If Jon is limited to one trip, we will at least be able to choose whether he travels for court or for our 'gotcha' day. I'm leaning towards the latter - something tells me that traveling by myself will be much easier on the first trip!

p.s. we're unofficially #9 on the girl list!

April 8, 2010

#12 Girl/#5 Sibling!

A movement of 3 on the "sibling" list and suddenly we're back to thinking that this might happen! Wow! We continue to be open to either a single girl or a girl and a sibling -- we are so excited to see what He has planned for us.

And... we're back to 'crunching' the numbers. We can't help ourselves, despite everyone's great advice to relax. With this kind of movement, we might - just might - get a referral in June after all, which would mean that we might - just might - pass court before it closes for the rainy season! Pray pray pra[y]ise praise praise...

April 4, 2010

Waiting

Waiting.

If Waiting is supposed to teach me patience, it should be fired for failing miserably.

Waiting wasn't difficult when we were expecting Matthew. After being (oh so very!) surprised by the unexpected, 9 months did not seem like nearly enough time to get used to the idea.

Waiting for our daughter, however, feels like an eternity. How long ago it seems that we first researched adoption... prayed... completed the paperwork... prayed... met with our social worker... prayed... read books, studied Ethiopia, crunched numbers, rearranged rooms, poured over baby names, and - you guessed it! - prayed.

Easter 2010. Our dossier is completed. Her nursery is finished. Her closet is full of clothes and toys. Her name is tentatively chosen.

And so we wait.

This past month, referrals by our agency came to a sudden, screeching halt. Not coincidentally, we suspect, the same month our agency's Ethiopia program director and staff had their time consumed by inter-agency and governmental meetings regarding the new travel requirement that has many adoptive families like us scrambling emotionally and financially to come to terms with a second trip.

Many people ask why it takes "so long" to adopt a child if the need is so great. (Of course, their perception of the time that it takes is tainted by my own impatience!) A significant amount of investigation and paperwork must be completed to confirm a child's eligibility for adoption and prepare the child's file for "referral" to an adoptive family. While the need for forever families is great, there is an equally great need to ensure that children are protected, that adoption is their best option, and that their individual circumstances are understood so that they are correctly matched with their families. Because government and agency resources are limited, the referral process takes time.

And so we continue to wait.

Excited. Frustrated.

Hopeful. Anxious.

With the slowing of referrals in March, if referrals return to the usual rate in April with no "catch up," our adoption timeline will be pushed out another month - we should not expect to receive a referral until late June or July.

A month delay in referral may mean another two months delay between referral and bringing our daughter home. Ethiopia courts close 1 - 2 months during the rainy season, usually around July/August/September. With that in mind, a June/July referral may mean a court date delayed until as late as October, and a Gotcha Day pushed out to November or December.

Emotions run wild. I am mentally pacing the floor, trying to keep busy to distract myself from the interminable wait. I borrow other people's children under the pretense of playdates for Matthew - a feeble attempt to ease the longing in my heart for my own daughter.

My clock is ticking.

Waiting.

March 29, 2010

Nursery

We painted the nursery! Well... actually, I had the lady at the paint store recommend the color, I bought the paint, and my wonderful, incredible, perfect sister painted the entire room while we were in Seattle. I "helped" add the dots today, and voila! the nursery is transformed from sterile white to warm browns with word art that couldn't be more perfect.

March 24, 2010

Travel Requirement Update

The latest rumor, unconfirmed by our agency: there is now a sign at the Addis Ababa court saying that the requirement having parents appear in court for the adoption hearing has been put on hold for an indefinite time. Please join us in praying that this is correct!

March 17, 2010

Gain vs. Loss

In the many hours of adoption education that we completed, one thesis statement still nags at me: "Adoption is built on loss." Yet, is not life itself built on loss? Because we live in a sinful world, we are immersed in loss - our very lives are lost without Christ. The most acute losses in our child's life predate adoption. To me, adoption is about gain after loss -- gaining a home, gaining a family, gaining opportunities, gaining love -- and I will gain every bit as much as she will.

I appreciate the following story, shared by another adoptive family:

***They recently spoke with an Ethiopian pastor in their hometown. The pastor grew up in Addis Ababa, the capital of Ethiopia. Raised Orthodox, he became an engineer and worked in that career for six years. After being introduced to Christ, he became a believer and came to the U.S. to get a seminary education so that he can eventually return and minister to his own people. He kept thanking this family for adopting two little boys. They kept assuring him that they are the ones being given the gift.

They then asked him how he felt about people saying negative things about Americans adopting Ethiopians - what was his opinion of taking children out of their heritage and culture and raising them as Americans? He just smiled and said, "Who is saying this? Americans or Ethiopians?" They told him they had only heard it from Americans.

He said, "Yes. Americans do not know poverty. Ask any person who has seen the real situation and they will not say these things." He was very passionate about this subject. He said, "The one thing these children need is someone to call Mom and Dad and to love them and make them part of their family. That is the most important thing. Does not compare to culture." He was very clear that he believes adoption is a very good thing for his people.***

I have never seen her photo, yet my daughter is the most beautiful girl in the world to me. I have never kissed her cheek, yet I can sense its softness beneath my lips. I have never held her hand, yet I can feel her tiny fingers grasping mine. I have never heard her laugh, yet my heart fills with joy as her voice echoes in my heart. I have never heard her cry, yet I feel her pain and my heart breaks. I know her diapers stink and her temper flares. I know she will bring me joy as well as sorrow, blessings as well as challenges. I know her, yet I have never met her.

She is my daughter, and I love her. Ruth 1:16

March 16, 2010

Saving My Own Child

I just enjoyed reading this NPR artiel, Adopting a Baby from Africa, Famous or Not, by Melissa Faye Greene, and especially the concluding quote: "Adoption is not rescue, not exactly, and yet I saved the lives of these children. Writing that, I feel no sense of nobility or virtue, nothing lofty at all. I saved the lives of my own children, which is a selfish act. I saved them for myself." (Sallie Tisdale)

March 15, 2010

...And More Travel Information

The latest information is that our first trip will be at the court date, which is a couple of weeks later than the signing of the adoption contract. That is both good and bad. The good is that it is more likely that we will get to meet the birth family who is giving our daughter up for adoption, because they are required to attend court as well. The bad is that the first trip will happen on a fixed date, on short notice, and the length of time between the first and second trips will liklely be 3 - 4 weeks -- too long to stay in country, but too short to fully recouperate between trips.

In the meantime, there are a lot of rumors on the adoption wire, including reports that an agency (not ours) is challenging the new rule, seeking to delay implementation until fall, and that other agencies are advising that the rule is not final. http://ethioadoptionnews.blogspot.com/ We continue to pray!

March 11, 2010

Latest Travel Information

The latest information that we have received gives us a new adoption schedule that looks something like this:

Referral: (June?) We will receive information about a girl 0 -12 months (or, a sibling group under 3) who is available for us to adopt. We will have 10 days to review and accept this referral. 2 - 3 weeks after we accept the referral, we will both travel to Ethiopia to meet our daughter and sign the adoption contract. Our agency plans to stagger travel groups, with “first trip” (contract signing) groups one week, “second trip” (taking children home) groups the next. With travel time, both trips will take 6 - 7 calendar days.

First Trip: (June/July?) Both Jon and I will spend about 3 days “on the ground” in Ethiopia, visiting and bonding with our daughter at the Hannah’s Hope transition home. We will not be permitted to leave Hannah’s Hope with her because we will not yet be her legal parents. We will have an opportunity to experience the culture, including meals and shopping. Then, we will return home and our daughter will stay at Hannah’s Hope for approximately 8 weeks - the time that it takes for her case to work its way through the Ethiopia court and U.S. immigration systems, verifying her eligibility for adoption and our eligibility to adopt, and finalizing the adoption under both Ethiopia and U.S. law.

Second Trip: (August?) At least one of us will spend another 3 days in Ethiopia, bonding with our daughter (we will have full custody, keeping her with us at our hotel) and going to our embassy appointment to obtain her U.S. IR-3 VISA. Because of the first trip, she will be a U.S. citizen when she enters the U.S. - no need to complete an additional citizenship application once we return home. Re-adoption in our state of residence will still be necessary to obtain a new birth certificate. If her birth mother or extended family is available, we will meet them during this trip as well.

As we consider taking two trips to Ethiopia over the course of a few months, we continue to pray that the requirement will be lifted or that there will be an immediate “good” that will come out of this for us. Whatever happens, however, we know that all things are being worked together for good - “to them that love God” is about perspective. Even while we groan under the burden of an additional trip, we have “peace . . . which passeth all understanding.” (Phil. 4:6-7)

March 10, 2010

New Travel Requirements

Ethiopia has just added an additional requirement: both adoptive parents must travel to Ethiopia to meet their child in person before the adoption proceeds through the Ethiopia court system. (Until now, adoptive parents could sign a Power of Attorney and have an agent sign the adoption contract.)

At least one parent must still travel to bring the child home, about 6 - 10 weeks after the contract is signed. It is highly unlikely that Jon will be able to make the 2nd trip. This is probably true for a lot of adoptive families. Each trip means about 10 days away from home (with travel time), which presents job and childcare challenges, and costs about $3,000 per person for airfare, food, and lodging.

We will learn more tomorrow during a conference call with our agency.

"All things work together for good..." Even unforseen trips to Ethiopia that require us to hold our daughter...and then leave her behind.

March 9, 2010

Travel Immunizations

We completed our consultation with the Travel Clinic nurse this morning. Results: we each received four immunizations - seasonal flu, H1N1, polio booster, and Hep A - and Jon received a fifth, his (very late) MMR booster. Our arms are sore. We also brought home pills for typhoid immunization, and will get prescriptions filled for altitude medicine and antibiotics closer to our travel date.

Preventive health measures: $620. Not getting deathly ill while traveling: priceless.

March 6, 2010

Work, Play, Rejoice.

WORK. The bank where Jon worked for the past 4+ years was closed by the FDIC. To say that work has been challenging the past 12 months is an understatement. Although his employment continued to assist the acquiring bank with the transition, it was only a matter of time before Jon would be unemployed. Our greatest concerns were (a) whether unemployment (of any length of time) would delay our adoption plans, and (b) how far of a commute Jon would have to accept to find a new job without relocating. Both worries were for naught. On Monday, March 8, Jon begins a new position as Controller at The Fruit Company, just a short drive from home. Jon is very excited about the opportunity and looks forward to the new (good!) challenges it brings.


PLAY. After a very long travel day, we arrived home from The Big Island of Hawaii a few hours ago. Perfect location, perfect weather, perfect trip. From driving through the lush Waimea valley, to snorkeling in the chrystal water above coral reefs, not a day went by that we didn't wonder when we will go back... and with whom! On our last trip 8-odd years ago, we would never have dreamed that our next visit would include a 3-year old boy who we adore beyond words. This time, we knew that our next trip will include at least one more traveler - our beloved daughter. We love sharing the things that we enjoy with our children!
  

                                           
REJOICE. We have tried to be faithful this past year, remembering to rejoice and give praise always -- in the seemingly best of times, as well as in the seemingly worst of times. (Phil. 4)

#18 Girl/#8 Sibling!

December 3, 2009

October 28, 2009

Heartache and Joy

Nana. During the 85 days following her diagnosis, some combination of Jon, Angela and Matthew had the privilege of spending nearly 50 days in Seattle with Nana.  With much effort, Nana came down for Matthew's 3rd birthday party, held early on October 3. Her greatest regret was that she will not be here as he grows up. Two and a half weeks later, with Jon by her side reading Psalm 139, Judy passed away.

Judith was born November 27, 1944 in San Francisco, California. Practical, hardworking, and thoughtful, she especially enjoyed spending time with her family, reading historical novels, traveling throughout the U.S. and Europe, watching romantic comedies, decorating her home, and taking pleasure in her beautiful rose garden. Judy peacefully passed away at home in Lake Forest Park, Washington on October 20, 2009, surrounded by love. She was preceded in death by her father and mother, Duer and Marcella Johnson, and brother, Richard. She will be dearly missed by daughter Jill, son Jon and his wife Angela, grandson Matthew, and son Kevin and his wife Danielle.

We will miss you, Nana.

Waiting List. With our home study complete, Angela hand-delivered our dossier to AGCI on October 7. On October 13, while we were in Seattle with Judy as her health took a turn for the worse, we got the call that we are #47 on the baby girl waiting list. Our paperwork will now be sent to Ethiopia for translating and processing. In the next 8 - 10 months, we will receive our "referral" - information about the little girl who will become our daughter.

Immigration. On October 29, we travel with our neighbors, Bob and Cheri, to the Department of Homeland Security U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services office in Yakima for an appointment to "capture [our] biometrics." (We really hope that is just code for fingerprinting.) CIS will then complete its background check on our family and approve our application for immigration/citizenship for our daughter. The only thing about this appointment that we are looking forward to is spending time with Bob and Cheri. Gas: $60. Six hours in a car with good friends, with nothing to do but talk: Priceless!

September 30, 2009

Responding to Challenges

The following challenges are a common theme in some of the comments that we have linked under "Reading List." They nevertheless caught me off guard and unprepared when they were made to me in person.

Despite the gentleness with which the views were expressed, I found myself getting defensive and struggling to find the words to respond. I resolved to better prepare for future challenges, so that I will have a "ready defense" that can be delivered calmly and thoughtfully. I will continue to hone these responses as time goes on - this will always be a work in progress.

In the end, there are many people who are critical of international adoption, and I will probably not change their minds, whatever I say. That’s okay, as long as I am satisfied that I have articulately explained my position and perhaps - just perhaps - given them another perspective.

Challenge: I think that it is better to provide families in [Ethiopia] with the resources to keep their children, instead of taking their children from them. (Bluntly, the “rich American parents stealing the poor African children” perspective.)

Response: There is absolutely a need to provide voluntary charity to assist families in every country to care for their own children. One of the reasons we selected AGCI as our agency is the in-country support that it offers expectant mothers. Such support, however, will not eliminate the need for adoptive families for Ethiopian children, any more than similar resources have eliminated the need for adoptive families for American children. We understand and treat with kindness parents in the U.S. who give their children up for adoption, and the families who adopt them (unwed teenage parents who chose adoption were recently lauded by Dr. Drew on national TV). Why should we do less for parents in Ethiopia and the families who adopt their children?

In addition to a higher rate of abandoned and voluntarily-relinquished children, there is generally a much higher rate of orphans in Ethiopia. This is not a “myth,” despite what some critics loudly proclaim. In a country that has been devastated by AIDS, the U.N. estimates that there are 10 million children in Ethiopia who have lost at least one parent.

Challenge: We should be careful judging living conditions in [Ethiopia] by Western standards.

Response: I agree that we should not judge a child's welfare by the living conditions she may have, whatever country she is in. I believe that a child is better off living in a cardboard box - whether under a bridge in Seattle or on a street corner in Addis Ababa - with a loving biological parent, than in a log home in *** with a loving adoptive family. I also believe, however, that there are parents in both the U.S. and Ethiopia who have legitimate reasons for giving up their children, and that there are parents in both the U.S. and Ethiopia who fail to provide minimal safety and care for their children. Adopting these children into loving homes, whether within their birth country or internationally, is preferable to raising these children in orphanages or leaving them on the streets. Note: 70% of children adopted internationally were previously in institutional group homes. http://www.aspe.hhs.gov/

Challenge: Adoptive children are robbed of their culture.

Response: Ethnicity should not limit a child's paramount right to a loving family. Children, regardless of where in the world they are born, do not deserve to grow up in an orphanage, nor do they deserve to be physically abused or neglected, in the name of culture or otherwise.

In parts of Ethiopia, 54% of girls are subject to painful and dangerous female "circumcision." The procedure, completed without anesthetic or antibiotics, can result in infections and hemorrhaging at the time, and complications during childbirth later. unicef.org/infobycountry/ethiopia_18246.html
Child marriages are also traditional in Ethiopia. Although illegal, child brides (some pre-puberty) are still common, and over 56% of girls are married before they reach the age of 18. npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=6560441 In the U.S., we remove children from their homes and prosecute their parents when they participate in (sub)culture with similar practices.

I am not advocating removing children from their parents because of cultural practices, however reprehensible they may be. I am also not criticizing Ethiopian culture as a whole. In fact, Ethiopia has a rich culture filled with many laudable features and practices. We are excited and proud to link our family with Ethiopia. My point is simply this: leaving children to grow up in orphanages to preserve their birth culture wrongly idolizes culture and places general cultural practices ahead of an individual child’s well being.

Challenge: Everyone wants a baby from Africa these days!

Response: Some people incorrectly characterize international adoption trends as “fads.” In fact, trends can be understood in light of country conditions.

A few decades ago, many U.S. parents adopted children from Korea and Viet Nam. These countries were devastated by war that left tens of thousands of children orphaned or abandoned. Many were Amerasian, subject to prejudice and mistreatment. Requirements placed on adoptive parents were low, and timelines were accelerated.

China continues to be the #1 country for international adoptions. Its poorly funded orphanages are overflowing (because of its 1-child law) and orphanage infant mortality rates were at one time above 50%. Today, while there are countless Chinese children who need homes, the process can take over 3 years, the standards placed on adoptive parents are uncommonly high (income requirements alone disqualify many middle-class families), and the cost of an adoption is 20%+ higher than other countries, discouraging many prospective adoptive parents.

Now, adoption trends are shifting to Ethiopia and certain other African countries. Ethiopia has a relatively high number of orphaned and abandoned children, and pervasive poverty resulting in low in-country non-relative adoptions. In addition, age, income, assets, education and other adoption requirements in Ethiopia are among the least restrictive of any country. Parents who are single, overweight, under 25, have been married only a few years, have more than two children in the home, have a modest net worth, and/or have an annual income of less than $10,000 per family member may not qualify to adopt from many countries other than Ethiopia.

Challenge: [some statement that ends with] Madonna!

Response: Madonna met Mercy when she was an infant in an orphanage. After waiting [2] years, during which Madonna donated significant money to fund in-country improvement projects, Mercy was still in an orphanage. Madonna finally chose to adopt Mercy into her family, rather than watch her continue to grow up in an orphanage. Critics suggest that Madonna should give Mercy's father money to keep Mercy in his home. Mercy's father - who abandoned her mother and did not visit her once in the orphanage, even as he was appearing on national television decrying Madonna - is presumed by these critics to be a loving man who would adequately care for his daughter if only he had the resources. If this entire scenario had played out in the U.S., the critics’ responses would be very different. Why should the response change - why should assumptions and the rights of the child change - based solely on geography, cloaked in terms like “culture?”

Challenge: Mothers in [Ethiopia] are paid to give up their babies.

Response: Actually, when a mother in Ethiopia chooses adoption, the adoptive parents may not pay her living expenses or give her any kind of support or payment. Even nominal gifts must be preapproved by the adoption agency to confirm that they do not rise to the level of a payment or bribe. In contrast, when an expectant mother in the U.S. gives her baby up for adoption, the adoptive parents can pay her living and medical expenses for several months leading up to birth.

Challenge: Children are kidnapped off the streets in [Ethiopia] for adoption!

Response: Children are kidnapped off the streets in the U.S. too! Children who are kidnapped by strangers - in any country - are almost always kidnapped for illegal, immoral purposes, not otherwise legal adoptions. There are more children over the age of 2 seeking homes than there are parents seeking to adopt them. In economic terms, the "supply" of children (other than babies) outweighs the "demand." There is little incentive to kidnap children - no economic reward - unless the purpose is something other than to have the children join a loving family. Yes, there is overall a greater demand for babies, and in very rare cases babies are stolen and sold in the context of adoption. This happens in every country and is unconscionable and illegal. Most children who are available for adoption, however, are voluntarily relinquished by their parents or caregivers, are orphans, or are removed from their homes with due process. We are confident that our baby will not have been bought or kidnapped, and we will likely have an opportunity to meet her biological family.

Conclusion: Of the nearly 150 million orphans worldwide, approximately 5 million orphans are in Ethiopia. http://www.unicef.com/ In 2009, there were 12,753 international adoptions in the U.S., including 2,277 adoptions of Ethiopian children. http://www.adoption.state.gov/ Yes, there are a host of underlying issues that need to be addressed. As we've said before, however, children grow up fast - faster than the problems of the world will be solved. In the meantime, our prayer is that the number of adoptions will increase exponentially, until every child has a "forever family" regardless of the child's - or the adoptive parent's - race, ethnicity, age, culture, martial status, sexual orientation, health, wealth, politics, or religion.

Ups and Downs

In the midst of our planning and excitement as we proceed with our adoption, Jon's mother Judy (Nana) was unexpectedly admitted to the hospital with AML (leukemia) on July 26. She immediately began 7-days of in-patient chemo, followed by another 3-weeks in the hospital struggling to survive the treatment. During that time, various combinations of Jon, Angela, and Matthew spent 15 days in Seattle.

First Meeting with Social Worker. In the middle of one extended Seattle visit, on August 10, we had our first appointment with the social worker assigned to prepare our home study. Rescheduling our meeting would have meant a month delay in our adoption. Because of various time challenges that we are already facing, this did not seem like a viable option. So, on August 10, we left Matthew in Seattle and drove 3 hours to meet with Barbara.

Well... we met with Barb when we finally arrived at her office. After initially exchanging E-mails with Barb to set up the meeting, Angela Mapquested directions to Barb's address. That address, complete with "Suite Number," is actually a P.O. box at a Fred Meyer. After much scrambling and frantic telephone calls, we arrived 30 minutes late. Apparently, Barb usually gives her physical address and directions during an intake telephone call that we missed out on. What would a meeting with a social worker be without a little excitement and miscommunication, after all?

After our interview with Barb, our neighbor, Cheri, and her boys met us at Red Robin with hugs and cherry crisp. That energized us for the drive back to Seattle.

Home Visit. Initially scheduled for August 26, our home visit was rescheduled. On September 2, Barb came to our home to continue our interview, meet Matthew, and generally form an opinion about our family. The night before our home visit, we learned that Judy's leukemia is not in remission and she is not a candidate for additional curative treatment. Since then, various combinations of Jon, Angela, and Matthew have spent 17 days in Seattle helping get things in order and maximizing our time with Nana.

Home Study Drafted. Barb sent us the first draft of our home study on September 19. It consists of 13 pages, of which about 8 are personal/family-specific. Our lives in a nutshell. Most importantly, it includes the statement "Jon and Angela are approved to adopt one healthy, female child up to the age of twelve months." After providing factual corrections to Barb, she sent the draft to AGCI. We are anxiously waiting for AGCI's approval of the home study so that Barb can finalize it and we can finally submit our dossier to Ethiopia.

Dossier. With the exception of the much-anticipated home study, our dossier is complete and ready to mail. It includes a letter from us to the Ethiopia Ministry of Women Affairs explaining why we want to adopt our daughter from Ethiopia and what we can offer her, along with financial information and documentation, reference letters, birth and marriage certificates, criminal background checks, and photos of our family and home.

August 24, 2009

Application

Our application is for a girl 0-12 months old. We are open to a baby girl who has a sibling of either sex who is younger than Matthew (3) at the time of placement. I have already started decorating the nursery. Gotta love pink!!!

August 18, 2009

Home Study

We are in the midst of our home study, the last piece of the paperwork puzzle to be completed. On August 10, we met with Barb, a social worker, for two hours in her office. On August 26, Barb will come to our home to continue the interviews. Time to clean house...

July 26, 2009

Paperwork...and More Paperwork

Over the past few weeks, we have completed over 400 pages of questionnaires, profiles, and adoption education materials and compiled most of the documents for our dossier (the packet of material that goes to Ethiopia). The dossier includes everything from birth and marriage certificates, to a letter from us explaining why we are interested in adopting from Ethiopia.

We must now spend several hours with a social worker, who will use our interviews, materials, and references from friends and family to complete a home study (a report on our family) that will become the last piece of our dossier. The home study should be completed by the end of September.

Once the home study is finished, our completed dossier will be sent to Ethiopia. 6 - 8 months later, we should receive a referral (information on the little girl who will become part of our family), and 2 - 3 months after that (about this time next year), we will be traveling to Ethiopia to bring her home!

Minor bumps in the road so far:
  • The FBI rejected Jon's request for a criminal background check because the ink-fingerprints he had taken at the sheriff's office were inadequate. Back to the sheriff's office for Jon... (how they manage to get usable fingerprints from criminals is beyond us!)
  • The state rejected our request for a certification of a notary (required as part of our dossier) because the notary's signature did not exactly match what they had on file. Back to the notary for Angela...
  • Photos. Who knew it would be so difficult to get "good" photos of ourselves for our dossier (that is, photos that Angela would actually share with the outside world).

June 22, 2009

More Steps Forward!

Today we met with AGCI staff in person at their Portland, Oregon headquarters. How good it is to meet the people we will be working with face-to-face and hear their answers to our questions. So many questions!

Tonight we will join our neighbors for dinner out at an Ethiopian restaurant. For them, it is their last "homework" assignment as they finish their mandatory adoption workbook Eyes Wide Open; for us, it is the first assignment we will complete, before we even get the workbook! We are so excited to get to share the experience with their family. With Angela's selective food preferences, it is guaranteed to be a dining adventure. Hopefully, they will have diet soda on hand... culinary authenticity be darned!




June 20, 2009

Pondering

What does the Lord require of [us]? To act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with [our] God. Micah 6:7-9

Book Commentary

There Is No Me Without You (Melissa Fay Greene)

Because I am recommending this book (see Reading List), I am compelled to briefly counter some of the conclusions drawn by the author, Melissa Fay Greene. Please take this for what it is– my personal analysis of the underlying facts– and do not let my conclusions or Greene’s conclusions deter you from experiencing the heart of this story. In the end, you may not agree with me, but at least you’ll know where I stand!

1. Greene concludes that Americans are (a) stingy (b) with Africa. In the Q&A epilogue, Greene reiterates a theme throughout her book: “We think we are big givers, we Americans, but, proportionately, our nation is at the very bottom, the very stingiest of the Western democracies sharing their wealth with Africa.” Both parts of this statement are incorrect.

(a) Americans are stingy. On the contrary, Americans are empirically among the most charitable in the world. Three out of four U.S. families donate money to charity at an average rate of 3.5 % of pre-tax household income, or 2% of U.S. GDP. 50% of Americans also volunteer their time. To head off an obvious objection, note that most of Americans’ charitable giving – about two thirds – and a majority of their volunteer time does not go to “religious” activities. Arthur C . Brooks, Who Really Cares, Basic Books, 2006, citing various sources.

Greene correctly states that the U.S. government gives less foreign aid as a percentage of GDP (less than .02%) than some other countries, but this number ignores the total giving by Americans. Americans, unlike many in the rest of the world, generally value private charity above public funding, so it is no surprise that individual giving far outpaces government aid by any measure.

“[G]iving at the private level is a foreign concept to [Europeans].” Studies ten years ago found that Americans overall give 3.5 times more than the French, 7 times more than Germans, and 14 times more than Italians. Adjusting for variables like average income and tax burden, the results barely change. Charitable giving in recent years has become so irrelevant in Europe that it is no longer evaluated. Who Really Cares, citing John Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project.

Private Charity vs. Public Aid. Like many people, Greene seems to confuse charity (which is, by definition, voluntary) with tax-based (compelled) public aid. One is not generous because one supports tax-funded programs: giving away other people’s money is easy. There may be legitimate reasons for government social programs and foreign aid– that is a discussion for another day– but personal generosity is not one of them. Yet, “[f]or many people, the desire to donate other people’s money displaces the act of giving one’s own.” Studies show that people who believe that the government is responsible for increasing income equality are substantially less likely to volunteer their time or donate their money than people who do not believe this. Who Really Cares, citing various sources.

I prefer private (voluntary) charity to public (compelled) aid for a number of reasons. First, charity is Biblical: “And now abideth faith, hope, charity, these three; but the greatest of these is charity. 1 Cor. 13:13. In addition to or as a subset of charity, tithing is called for broadly, including a 10% “social” tithe (Lev.27:30-33, Num. 18:20-26) and an additional 3% “poor” tithe (Deut. 14:28-29). The “social” tithe funds health, education, and welfare ministries, worship, missions, and administration of justice, while the “poor” tithe is earmarked solely for the needy.

Second, charitable organizations are more efficient, effective, and responsive than government agencies. Charitable donations experience less reduction by bureaucratic overhead and “middlemen,” including corrupt foreign officials who divert aid for their own purposes. If a charity squanders money, donors shift their support to more responsible organizations. If a government agency squanders money, tax-payers are asked to pay more to fix the problem. The effectiveness and responsiveness of non-governmental entities is even evident in anecdotal accounts throughout Greene’s book.

(b) Americans are not sharing enough with Africa. Some would say more generally that Americans are not sharing enough with the world. After all, only about 2% of U.S. charitable giving is “international,” with 98% remaining in the U.S. In fact, American charity internationally is competitive, when both foreign aid (.01 - .02% of GDP) and foreign charity (.04% of GDP) are factored together.

Indonesia 2004. Consider foreign aid to Indonesia following the 2004 tsunami disaster. Germany gave $674 million, Japan $500 million, Australia $380 million, and the U.S. $350 million. Comparing government aid alone would lead one to conclude that the U.S. did not do its part, and some publicly berated President Bush himself as being personally uncaring because of the lack of U.S. government aid. (Whether he personally donated his own money was irrelevant: he did not give away enough of his constituents' money.) Ultimately, however, Americans donated $1.5 billion, outpacing nearly every other country by any measurement, with individual, private donations outpacing government aid three-to-one, a phenomenon largely confined to the U.S. Who Really Cares, citing “Helping the Survivors,” Economist, January 8, 2005. Nevertheless, the focus remained on the amount the government pledged, and Americans as a whole were harshly criticized.

Foreign Aid Budget Presents Incomplete Picture. Focusing on the U.S. foreign aid budget in a vacuum erroneously ignores the disproportionately high level of private charity in the U.S. In addition, the U.S. foreign aid budget taken on its own may be misleading because it does not reflect significant indirect aid, nor does it account for the variety of types of aid or the wide range of motives and results.

[Foreign] aid is seldom given from motives of pure altruism, for instance it is often given as a means of supporting an ally in international politics; it may also be given with the intention of influencing the political process in the receiving nation. . . . Besides criticism of motive, aid may be criticized simply on the grounds that it is not effective: i.e., it did not do what it was intended to do or help people it was intended to help. Excerpt from Wikipedia.com, Aid, 2009.

U.N World Food Programme. To examine one specific type of aid may be anecdotally helpful. The world’s largest humanitarian agency, the U.N. World Food Programme, receives approximately 40% of its funding from the U.S. government. Of the 87 donor countries contributing $2.7 billion in 2007, the U.S. was the #1 donor, contributing $1.2 billion, or .01% of its GDP. In contrast, France, a vocal critic of U.S. aid, contributed only $32 million, or .001% of its GDP. Contributions to WFP 2007 report at wfp.org.

Value Judgments. Are some charitable purposes more important – more valuable – than others? To someone who values art and education, donating time and money to public broadcasting may be more “right” than donating to a children’s hospital. To some, relief efforts in Africa may be “better” than relief efforts in Indonesia, and Ethiopian orphans may be more “deserving” than Costa Rican orphans. (An increasing number of people seem to oppose foreign humanitarian aid altogether, instead arguing that those dollars should be allocated to domestic needs, as cuts are made across the board.) Many people criticize how U.S. foreign aid is allocated, and no two people can agree on how best to spend those dollars. That is the beauty of charity: if each person voluntarily and generously gives his time and money to the charitable purpose close to his heart, whether domestically or internationally, religious or secular, the world as a whole will be a better place. Rather than asking “what can the government do to help” and then searching the tax rolls to find “better” ways to spend other people’s money (which is neither generous nor charitable), we should ask “what can I do to help” and then search our own hearts to find “better” ways to allocate our own resources.

2. Greene blames pharmaceutical companies and U.S. patent policies. There may have been specific wrongs committed by drug companies in connection with AIDS medications in Africa; I have not researched Greene’s particular allegations in any depth. I can say with certainty, however, that some of the criticisms of the pharmaceutical industry by Greene are gravely misplaced. I start with the premise that AIDS medications are no more valuable than other life-saving and life-changing medications. Of the record number of drugs now in development in the U.S., 750 are cancer-related, over 300 are heart disease/stroke-related, nearly 100 are for Alzheimer’s/dementia, the list goes on. Accordingly, whatever justification one finds for regulating the pharmaceutical industry’s policies on AIDS medications must apply equally to all medications and across all borders. Equally tragic are the experiences of an individual dying of cancer and an individual dying of AIDS, an individual in Ethiopia who cannot afford a life-saving drug and an individual in the U.S. who cannot afford a life-saving drug.

Price-gouging or cost-averaging? For every “hit” drug that is developed, years of research and development and millions of dollars are invested in drugs that never make it to market, or make it to market and are later pulled in the face of lawsuits regarding unforeseen side effects. According to Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, U.S. pharmaceutical companies invested $65 billion in R&D in 2008, or 8 times the level of R&D investment per employee of all other manufacturing industries, according to a study by The Wharton School. The cost of a “hit” drug must, inherently, absorb the staggering costs of the “miss” drugs as well as generate profits averaged over all the “hits” and “misses.” What looks like price-gouging to one examining the cost of a single drug in a vacuum may look like legitimate pricing to another examining the overall cost of the industry.

A Recurring Theme: Value Judgments. To a person who is starving, the wheat farmer may be acting unconscionably by charging $5 a bushel. To a person who is freezing, the hotelier with empty rooms charging $200/night may be price-gouging. At the end of the day, free market capitalism remains the most efficient economic model resulting in the most productivity, and private charity remains the most efficient social aid model resulting in the most benefit. These two models, grounded in Biblical principles, have historically set the U.S. apart from the rest of the world, and practiced in conjunction with one another make the world a better place.

Patent protection. Drug companies rely on patents to protect their property. Intellectual property may be more costly than real property, and generally receives less protection. A farmer may spend $2 million to purchase a wheat farm. That farmer will own that wheat farm – generating life-sustaining food – indefinitely. His ownership does not expire in 10 or 20 years. In contrast, drug companies spend an average of $800 million to bring one new drug to market. Without worldwide patent protection giving the pharmaceutical company the time – and the right – to recoup its investment and make a profit, investment in R&D will decline and fewer new, life-saving drugs will be available to anyone.

Public research, private profits. Greene criticizes the U.S. policy that permits government-funded research to be given to for-profit drug companies, with profits shared 50/50. Overall, this is in practice a good policy. After a new drug is initially identified, it still takes many years and tens of millions of dollars to develop the drug and bring it to market. Greene herself acknowledges that the rights to the “interesting molecule” that became the anti-AIDS/HIV drug AZT were purchased by Burroughs Welcome before its impact on HIV was confirmed. How many other “interesting molecules” are purchased and amount to naught? (Other claims to AZT and challenges to the patent were resolved in favor of Burroughs Welcome by neutral judges.)

Because the U.S. government is not, and should not, be in the pharmaceutical business, 50% profit sharing for little more than an idea, with no ongoing R&D to market hard dollar investment, is appropriate. How much longer would it have taken, and how many more people would have suffered in the interim, if the government had been relied upon to bring AIDS medication to market. If drug companies then “price gouge” the new medicine, the U.S. government may earmark its 50% share of those profits to subsidize the purchase of the drugs. Better yet, private charity may be used to subsidize life-saving and life-changing medicines.

Regulation has a steep cost. We should avoid “throwing the baby out with the bathwater” or, more accurately, “splitting the baby” by adopting policies that effectively guarantee that until everyone will have the drugs, no one will have them. Put more eloquently by Dr. Elizabeth M. Whelan, president of the American Council on Science and Health: “Any government form of price control on pharmaceuticals represents a case of killing the goose who laid the golden egg. . . . It is crystal clear that countries with price controls do not have companies that produce new, innovative drugs. The United States stands alone now as the leader in new drug production – accounting for approximately 90 percent of new medicines.”

Work to get your piece of the pie, share it, and change the world. Glaxo Welcome f/k/a/ Burroughs Welcome, the owner of the AZT patent that expired in 2005 that is harshly criticized by Greene, is part of GlaxoSmithKline, a publicly traded company. If you believe that GlaxoSmithKline or any other company is “wrongly” profitable, or if you just want to influence their practices, invest your hard-earned dollars in the company and use your investment earnings– a direct reflection of the company’s profits –and shareholder vote to “do good,” however you may define that.

*Note: GlaxoSmithKline’s stock price, reflecting their actual and expected earnings, has declined 40% over the past year. Despite the former “extravagant price tag” on AZT cited by Greene, in 2004, the year before its AZT patent expired, the value of GSK stock traded on the New York Stock Exchange increased 17%, not a particularly outrageous increase relative to other non-pharmaceutical companies, despite alleged price gouging.

Whether my paycheck or dividend check says “ACME DRUG CO.” or “ACME SCHOOL DISTRICT,” I have a personal choice to make with respect to what I do with the resources I have. I can buy AZT for one suffering person. I can love one hurting child. I can do my part to change the world.

*Note: Because my net worth is over $100,000, I am one of the wealthiest people in the world. If my net worth were over $500,000, I would be in the top 1% (I’ll be there in my lifetime, God-willing). The typical (median) person worldwide has a net worth of only $2,200. Eduardo Porter, Study Finds Wealth Inequality is Widening Worldwide, The New York Times, December 6, 2006. The average worldwide income is around $7,000/year, with the world median income at only $1,700/year. Average Income Worldwide, The Boston Globe, October 7, 2007. Because my income is over $1,700/year and my net worth is over $2,200, I may not point my finger at the “wealthy” other person (or company, or government) and cry “do more,” for he is me.
_______________________________________
Who Really Cares. America’s Charity Divide: Who Gives, Who Doesn’t, and Why It Matters. We all know we should give to charity, but who really does? In this provocative and controversial study of America’s giving habits, Arthur C. Brooks, a Louis A Bantle Professor of Business and Government Policy at Syracuse University’s Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs, shatters stereotypes about charity in America – most notably, the myth that the political Left is more compassionate than the Right. Brooks, a preeminent public policy expert, spent years researching giving trends in American, and even he was surprised by what he found. In Who Really Cares, he identifies the forces behind American charity: strong families, church attendance, earning one’s own income (as opposed to receiving welfare), and the belief that individuals – not government – offer the best solution to social problems. Beyond just showing us who the givers and non-givers in America really are today, Brooks shows why charity matters – not just to givers and to recipients but to the nation as a whole. He demonstrates conclusively that giving is crucial to our economic prosperity, as well as to our happiness, health, and our ability to govern ourselves as a free people. Back Cover, Who Really Cares, Arthur C. Brooks, Basic Books, 2006.